He doesn't get into my top 3. Hudson, Sheron, Norwood all above him. I've probably not seen his best performances though.
His rather obvious giving up at Aldershot has again made me question his leadership too. Something his performance at Rochdale, especially after our 3rd / 4th goal, had restored.
Lots of people suggesting other players that if we want to go up and do well need replacing. Well Hogan is in that list for me both as a player and a captain.