Jump to content

Latics either or


Recommended Posts

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram 1984-87 or Paul Gerrard (It must be noted, this is Andy Goram 1984-1987, not the 20 stone version)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or David Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Denis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck None! - ok Jepson then

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan (Ouch, that's tough!)

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

 

Rick Holden (no contest in terms of ability no matter how much I think of Eyres as a person)

Joe Royle (Frizzell before my time, and Joe for his faults took us to places we could never of imagined)

Porter (20+ goals in a season is a landmark acheivement for Latics)

Earl Barrett (no contest in terms of ability and left a legacy behind - RRE)

Kilkenny (no much between them - but seemed to have more affinity with Latics than Ritchie)

Andrews (Go Hard or Go Home season was great - and Julie was a good nickname)

Phil Starbuck (because he has left a bigger impression on my than many other players - for the wrong reasons mind)

Shaun Garnett (Alf was a good servant in some poor times - Branston, forgetable in everyway)

Roger Palmer (All-time top scorer and just a bit mysterious - though Frankie was a class player, you could still see that in the Legends game)

Sheriden (tough call. But was a beacon of quality in otherwise dire time, been here longer, potentailly a very good manager. Redders - one season of brilliance and the ultimate finish, but Shez has done more)

BEFORE MY TIME - my Dad raves about Fryatt.

Barlow (tough call, but Pudding on a Muffin and the fact he was from Oldham swings it - though Irwin must be one of the best players to have ever played for us in terms of what he acheived in his entire career)

Halle (Bad teeth, commitment, played in our best ever team)

Gerrard (would have been Goram apart from that Cardiff game - still scarred by that game)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn*

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw*

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

 

Many affected (in particular the Fitz one) by the fact the alternative was before my time.

 

* Never saw either player play, thus chosen from what I've heard from the old man.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck (2 goals at grimsby swayed it - both gash)

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn (only becuase of the record)

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw (b4 my time)

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow (i know im supposed to but refuse to choose, both legends)

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard (first spell)

Edited by palmer1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or David Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfearn or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or David Eyres ....... see my user tag!

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell ....... only manager that 'everyone' knows the name of!

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter ........ for me more of a fans player!

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall ........ hard one, but 'the pearl' just about edges it for me!

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens ...... difficult again, but i never will forget that stamp and it's consequences... killer wins!

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson ..... wayno! wayno!

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck ...... can't recall either...

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston ...... more effort from 'alf' and he didn't think he was the almighty!

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn ....... cruel, cruel! 'the dodge' for me!

Neil Redfearn or John Sheridan ....... sorry shez, there will only ever be ONE penalty take like that!

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw ......... black n white days IMO, far, FAR too young to remember!!

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow ........ 'born and bred' , puddin in a muffin wins this one!

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle .......Gunnar gets my vote!

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard ...... seven goals??? i thought you were supposed to be good? PG tips this one!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck - neither

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfearn or John Sheridan - OK, only one season, but what a season. Should have kept hold of him, IMO. Great player.

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard - first stint, obviously

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall Too young to remember barrett

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

 

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter - easily capable of matching CPs scoring record if he could have stayed fit. Would have loved LB here 2 years earlier.

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall (though given the choice it would be Clint Hill)

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck - Must we- God no! OK then Rickers!

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston - purely for being an amusing drunk

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn - pah! like there is any choice, sorry Frank, it could have been anyone against Rog and you all lose.

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw - only ever saw Shaw and that was at the end of his Latics career and the start of mine. Not really much opinion to be honest.

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

 

KtF,

 

Derek.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Rick Holden or David Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell - tough one but it has to be JR for the "Pinch Me" era

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck - hmmm...

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn - attacking midfielder c.f. out and out striker? I can't choose - our fortunes dramatically changed when Bunn arrived.

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw - Never saw Fryatt

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard - first time around obviously.

Edited by martjs
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or David Eyres - Ricky was the best crosser I have ever seen, but Eyresy gave us some quality after years of :censored:!

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell - Uncle Joe for me as Frizz was before my time

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter - Beckett by a mile, He would have score 30-35 last season no danger

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall - Barrett by a mile an insult to compare them, not in the same League

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens - Both jumped up little gob:censored:es, but Wellens dictates a game. KK trys to win it on his own

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson - Wayno just

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck - Rocket was finding some form, but spat his dummy out and walked when Whitehall arrived.

Shaun Garnett or Guy Branston - Garnett great servant, much needed experience in a young team after Redmond and Fleming bailed.

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn - The Dodger or 'Mr. Reliable' as the owd fella deemed him.

Neil Redfearn or John Sheridan - Shez, different types of players but without the guile of Shez we'd be playing in the Conference.

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw - Before my time, but Shaw was here longer and in two spells

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow - Andy Barlow, OLdham lad eats puddin' on a muffin. He'll do for me!

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle - Gunnar, great servant

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard - Andy Goram, forget March-April '02, kept many games respectable

Edited by oafcprozac
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres...holden,perfect crosser of a ball,and good hats

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell...big joe.was a rollercoaster and wembly.

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter..beckett...quality

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall...you will never beat earl barrett

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens..wellens

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnsonandrews...but only just

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck....diego cerveza or whatever hes called

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston...garnett

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn...roger palmer

Neil Redfern or John Sheridan...sheridan....just

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw...shaw.didnt see fryatt

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow...irwin.fantastic defender.

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle...halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard..andy goram first time

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or Davied Eyres - Not old enough to remember Holden enough, but know enough and seen enough from glimpses that he takes it over Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell - Royle...without doubt

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter - Porter....but if Beckett hadn't the fitness issues in his career holding him back, it'd be a photo finish

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall - Again, didn't see enough of Earl, but seen enough and heard enough on Vids. To be honest, ya can't compare some of these....as the levels they played at in their time are different

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens - Lol....everysingle:censored:ingday! The day KK can be injured and do a Bradford away, then maybe....

Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson - Can't believe the post originator has JJ over Andrews....lol....maybe in another lifetime, not this one

Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck - I think general consensus is that Starbuck is THE WORST player ever to have worn the shirt

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston - Mr no nonsense vs Mr No sense at all......and the winner is....

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn - Tight one, but has to be Palmer....again, just too young to be able to say my definitive view and Bunn is the nicest guy you'll ever meet (Palmer might be too) but on the pitch, Palmer is the main man

Neil Redfearn or John Sheridan - Hmmmm....anyone who has the balls and the ability to do what Redders did....step up and score, is the ultimate legend....only title we've won in decades thanks to one man, in one moment, in one single second of destiny. Ok, Shez gave away the pen, but Redders had to score it...

Jim Fryatt or David Shaw - Can't comment

Dennis Irwin or Andy Barlow - By all accounts, Irwin....too young again for a full opinion, but from videos and how my older mates talk if Irwin hadn't gone to them, I think some would still talk about him as one of the greatest ever.

Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle - Halle...everytime....absolute hero of mine when I was a kid.

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard - Again, it's my older mates who tell me about Goram and the odd snippet, but any Latics fan has to forget his 2nd stint here....his 1st stint, he was (I'm told) awesome.

 

Ha....I wasn't going to do this till I saw the 1st 3 foolishly went for Kilkenney over Wellens....hahaha....nice to see KK has brought the "home effect" too Leeds now...as I expected.

Edited by boundaryblue80
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rick Holden or David Eyres

Joe Royle or Jimmy Frizzell

Luke Beckett or Chris Porter

Earl Barrett or Fitz Hall

Neil Kilkenny or Richie Wellens

neither Wayne Andrews or Jermaine Johnson - it's 11 a side not 12....

neither Ronnie Jepson or Phil Starbuck

Sean Garnett or Guy Branston

Roger Palmer or Frankie Bunn

Neil Redfearn and John Sheridan

not Jim Fryatt or David Shaw - we have Porter and Palmer up front....

Dennis Irwin and Andy Barlow - you need a left back and a right back - Dennis has it over Gunnar

not Toddy Orlygsson or Gunnar Halle

Andy Goram or Paul Gerrard

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...