Depends what your saying, Scholes for a half season or :censored: on a free full time, i know who'd i'd take. There's no guarentee that Scholes will be so good in this league, who won't take us up on his own and for half a season is he worth it? Some players at the top level are amazing, but in the lower leagues cant cut it. Check Rob Lee.
Yep you liked :censored:, heck 95% of fans liked him, as to which brings me to question why Dickov hasn't brought him in yet when he is available 100%.