I have been watching football since 1967 and attending BP since 1974 and I think that most fans of around my age would agree that the thing that gave you the buzz to go back week after week in those days was the atmosphere on the terraces, regardless of what went on on the pitch.
Even when half full the Chaddy End was always electric because you could sing, swear, smoke and jump up and down to your heart's content, not to mention the regular surges from the back to the front of the stand. The regular invasions by away fans only added to the excitement as did the 'interaction' with them before and after games.
Away games were the same, getting to the ground, watching the match and getting back to the coach without getting your head kicked in was an achievement, you'd been on enemy territory and survived.
In today's sanitised football world with all seater segregated stadiums you will never be able to recreate the atmosphere of the terraces and as a result the 'youth' who used to make up a large percentage of the crowd are not going to be attracted to watch Latics in the forseeable future. A lot of people on here mock the young lads in the RRE for goading the away fans but that is partly why they come to matches, at their age its fun, just a shame they don't bring more of their mates.
And wtf is the matchday experience you're all talking about. Its the same as its always been. Meet mates at pub, have a few pints, go to game, go back to pub, talk about game, forget game, go home. What are you expecting at a football match? Pre game mud wrestling followed by a gourmet meal and champagne, and a blow job at half time? Its Latics ffs, pie and bovril if you're lucky and if they've sold out or the pie is cold THAT is your matchday experience. You might moan about it but you wouldn't stop attending because you got a cold pie.
Football at our level is dying, we all know the reasons so I won't repeat them but as long as we have a club to support I will continue to attend and hopefully the authorities will one day see sense and reintroduce standing, unsegregated,stadiums with a bit of hooliganism thrown in. Just watch attendances rise then!