Can't remember him being very very poor at any stage, he came in for the Macclesfield game which we won 3-1 and we were far more organised for it, we were poor as a team at home to Carlisle, Newport and Vale and Clarke didn't have his best games but of his 23 appearances we've only been beaten 5 times and we've won 12, he's also scored in 4 of the 12 victories, no doubt about it we are better with him than without and players like Edmondson are better for having him around.