I understand what your saying regarding the risks of taking Baxter back, personally I would sooner take the risk over Baxter (given his undoubted quality), than sign Erwin, if it was a straight choice between the two (which I'm sure its not).
I thought Bertrand did alright in his loan spell with us, I'm not saying I thought he would be a future regular starter in the Premier league and get capped by England, but I wouldn't say I wasn't overly impressed by him.
Anyway i was just expressing an opinion.
I didn't judge him on one game but on the entire length of his loan, hence I said "I remember Amos being on loan with us and not being overly impressed"
I specifically remember him having a nightmare in the Southampton game, hence I said " especially the Southampton game"
So to summarise I wasn't overly impressed with him during his loan period with us.