Could/should have been a brilliant player. In his first couple of seasons in the City team he was excellent, he just seemed to adapt straight away to the Premiership. Scored a few belting goals as well, and I remember some of his link up play with Elano being top class. I know he's had bad injury problems but I'm not convinced that's the only reason for him turning out the way he has. Unfortunately he's now another 'what could have been' in English football.